Cali Coffee: Drive-Thru Excellence and the Art of Customer Service in Fast Casual
In a recent episode of Fast Casual Nation, host Paul Barron sat down with Craig Avera, founder and CEO of Cali Coffee, to discuss how this Florida-based coffee chain is carving out its niche in an increasingly competitive beverage market. What started as a California transplant's vision in 2018 has evolved into a 13-unit operation that's doubling in size by year's end, proving that thoughtful execution can compete with industry titans like Starbucks and Dunkin'.
Avera's approach to real estate strategy reveals a sophisticated understanding of market dynamics that many emerging brands could learn from. Rather than chasing premium A-locations, Cali Coffee targets what Avera calls "A-locations that people don't know about" – sites with strong fundamentals but less obvious appeal. This strategy has paid dividends, with their Cooper City location becoming their busiest store despite being in a relatively unknown neighborhood. The brand's willingness to pay above market rates for endcap positions with drive-thru capabilities demonstrates their commitment to the format that drives 85% of their sales – a penetration rate that exceeds most QSR chains.
The operational excellence at Cali Coffee centers on their relay system for order-taking, borrowed from the Chick-fil-A playbook. During peak times, they deploy up to four team members to take orders in-line, achieving an impressive 45-second per-car throughput once orders are placed. This system, combined with their focus on handwritten "lid love" messages on every cup, creates a service experience that stands in stark contrast to the declining hospitality standards Barron notes are plaguing the fast-casual segment for the first time in a decade.
Menu strategy at Cali Coffee reflects a deep understanding of customer psychology and operational efficiency. Their signature coffee drinks comprise 65% of sales, with the Beverly (caramel vanilla), Snickerdoodle, and similar flavored beverages "keeping the lights on." The introduction of Hero Energy Drinks through a sister company captures younger demographics who want energy without coffee, while their grab-and-go food items deliberately avoid anything that could slow down service. This focused approach prevents menu paralysis while maintaining operational speed.
Perhaps most impressive is Cali Coffee's loyalty program performance, boasting a 90% participation rate that would make national chains envious. Their streamlined sign-up process – requiring only a phone number via text verification – eliminates traditional friction points. With over 250,000 loyalty members generating 400-500 new sign-ups daily, the program demonstrates how simplicity can drive engagement. The integration of mobile ordering with on-arrival preparation ensures quality isn't sacrificed for convenience.
As Cali Coffee eyes expansion beyond Florida, Avera's hub-and-spoke philosophy offers a masterclass in sustainable growth. Rather than scattered national expansion, they're building brand equity regionally, creating operational efficiencies and cross-market awareness. For restaurant professionals watching the beverage segment's rapid evolution, Cali Coffee's blend of operational excellence, customer-centric culture, and strategic patience provides a compelling blueprint for competing against established giants through superior execution rather than just capital.
Previous episodes
